Style Lessons from the 2014 Oscars

No I didn’t watch them, although I do own a TV and even spend some time watching it each week. However, my Twitter and Tumblr feeds blew up with this stuff all night Sunday and into the day Monday.

Whether we like to admit it or not, these men are at the peak of society. Men want to be them and women want to be with them. They have fame, fortune, and influence – all of which are indicative of a level of power. Yet even these apex men and their reputation are impacted by their appearance. Obviously some of it is fueled by a bottom-up mentality, in which people not as high up the social ladder will grab onto any apparent flaw or weakness in an attempt to level the playing field. But it’s not just fueled by jealousy, those who worship these celebrities look at their clothing as well. It’s a way to confirm that they really are as cool, put-together, and flawless as hoped for.

So here are the top things I learned from seeing all of the photos of the men at this year’s award ¬†ceremony.

Pay Attention to the Break

Whether it’s one of many things going wrong with a look, or the only problem to ruin perfection, pants that have too much break is a near omni-present issue at celebrity-attended black tie events. I get that not all of these guys are style gurus who care, but they are dressed by professionals who should know better. It’s getting to the point that I’m starting to think it’s a subtle way of indicating elite status in an occult group. That way people like me can write about how bad it looks but really they’re just signaling to each other that they’ve sold out their souls.

Kevin Spacey 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Barkhad Abdi 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Michael Fassbender 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Matthew Mcconaughey 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Standing Out Can Be Overrated

In the past I’ve written about the difference between dressing so people notice the man and dressing so people notice the clothes. When someone is at the social level these men are, the only reason a man should want people paying attention to his clothing, rather than paying attention to him, is when he’s trying to avoid recognition. Although there is the occasional trend setter, most guys who attempt to out-unique others just come across as lesser men trying to status-jockey within their own group.

If who the man is carries more social capital than his implied willingness to expose himself to risk by standing out, it’s better to emphasize the former over the latter.

Chris Hemsworth Elsa Pataky Oscars 2014 Red Carpet

Pharrell William 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Jared Leto 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

As a counter point to this argument, all of the attention-seeking outfits shown thus far (excluding Pharrell) are within a normal enough range of tradition as to be considered classic. Therefore, by choosing to embrace a little risk these men communicate that they don’t take themselves too seriously and enjoy dressing up for its own sake. Although Leto’s hair looks ridiculous, everything else about his wardrobe was spot on, making the cream dinner jacket a good tweak instead of a cry for help.

Proportion is Key

The three men who were the best dressed all had their proportions down to a science. Pant length, lapel width, button stance, and more are all in complete agreement with the natural build of each man.

Bradley Cooper 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Joseph Gordon Levitt 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

Leonardo DiCaprio 2014 Oscars Red Carpet

If DiCaprio and Levitt were to swap tuxes, they’d both look ridiculous, even if they were tailored to fit their bodies. What makes their individual appearances so strong is how well all of the minor details compliment their unique features.

What it really comes down to is, the higher a man climbs, the more he’s scrutinized for any apparent flaws. I could do this same post about a high-school band’s banquet with even worse offenses but no one would care. However, the mere fact that these are celebrities means they’re constantly under public scrutiny. If a man wants to maintain a hard-earned image of dignity, daring, respect, rebellion, or anything else, his style needs to be consistent as his reputation increases.

Meet The Author

Tanner is the founder and primary author of Masculine Style. He lives in Salt Lake City, Utah with his wife and two kids, and helps run Beckett & Robb - a men's clothing company built around custom suits and shirts.
  • Peregrine John

    I kinda dig Hemsworth’s tux, actually. DiCaprio and his look are something to reach for, for me, but Hemsworth reaching out into a different color while still looking classic is pretty nice.

    Interesting that only men have to conform to a hairsbreadth-narrow set of options, hide-bound as hell, making microscopic details so important. It’s because the look arises from within, or whatever, right. We all know the rationales. All very universal and human and such, of course.

    Applying that set of motivations to the women, we end up with an interesting conclusion, don’t we?

    • MasculineStyle

      It’s certainly more constricting for the men than it is for the women. It’s funny too because peacocking really works to a man’s advantage in some contexts but can seem overboard very quickly in formal occasions.

      I actually like all of the unique stuff (even Pharrell’s shorts) but do think it does the men more of a disservice than a service at events like this.

      • Peregrine John

        I was not liking the shorts, it being a formal affair, but I have to give him kudos for the big brass huevos.

        My idea of an ideal: wide variety of options with close attention to small details. That there is proper peacocking. No feather boas, though, please.

  • Drake

    I’m gonna second the vote for Hemsworth’s Tux. It was dark enough to still be properly formal, and the color stood out in a sea of black. Yes, it distracted for a moment when you saw it and went “Wait,is that purple?” But then you went right back to looking at him, rather than his clothes. It gives that pop from drawing the eye in, but is subtle enough to let your eye go again.

  • kfg

    If Hemsworth had stuck with the purple vest, maybe even purple lapels, it would have been smashing. I think he tried a bit too hard and pushed it over the edge with the purple jacket.

    Leto is wearing a tux. Levitt and DiCaprio are not. Those are suits.

  • Peregrine John

    I keep coming back to this and marveling at these well-advised and widely-viewed people not being able to manage something as simple as getting the break anything like correct. Did no one tell them their legs look like formal elephants? A couple measurements and 5 minutes of adjustment by any tailor’s apprentice and it’d be fixed. It’s just strange.

    The main takeaway for me is this: Go and do likewise. That tiny adjustment for huge (if largely subliminal to the viewer) improvement is inexcusable for any of us.

    • MasculineStyle

      I was only half joking when I said it must be a way to flash membership in an occult group. It’s such a simple detail and is so easy to alter that part of me wonders if there really is some intentional reason it’s missed.